arrow_back Genshin Impact Quests 
Lotos Somno Chapter: Act I
To the Wise
To prepare supplies for your adventure, you and Paimon come to the Grand Bazaar...
Talk to Nilou
Paimon:
Nilou, it's nice to see you again!
Nilou:
Oh, hey there, Traveler and Paimon!
Paimon:
Are you here for some shopping too?
Nilou:
That's right. Although there were a few hiccups here and there, the Sabzeruz Festival turned out to be a grand success!
Nilou:
And so, the theater wants to host a celebration event.
Nilou:
Do you two want to come? It'll be a really fun time!
Traveler:
A celebration event?
Nilou:
It's something like a tradition of ours. Whenever we wrap an important performance, we'll get together and unwind.
Nilou:
Rehearsals are exhausting... If you keep your nose to the grindstone, you're going to wipe yourself out sooner or later.
Nilou:
Mr. Zubayr, our manager, always says that celebrations aren't just for fun, but that they should also be occasions for reflection and review...
Nilou:
Hehe, but no one remembers that once the celebration starts. It's not like he can't also have some fun himself.
Paimon:
We've been to a lot of festivals during our adventures!
Paimon:
Will your celebration also have lots of yummy food and drinks?
Nilou:
Of course! We always do lots of eating, toasting, and gift-exchanging. We try really hard to show our appreciation for everyone.
Paimon:
Ahh, so we'll need to bring a present...
Paimon:
No way! Treat others how you want to be treated, right? Paimon already has a great gift in mind!
Paimon:
...But maybe you could lend Paimon some Mora first...?
Nilou:
Hahaha, it's fine! No need to stress, Paimon.
Nilou:
You can come, present or not. The gift exchange is just to make the celebration more entertaining.
Nilou:
You two being there would be the best gift of all! It'll also be a good time to introduce you to the rest of the theater.
Paimon:
Is something up?
Traveler:
A pity Dunyarzad can't also be here...
Nilou:
Yeah... but for now, it's more important for her to rest and recover.
Nilou:
I tried to visit her, but I got turned away at the door... The people there wouldn't listen to a single word I said.
Nilou:
All I could do was to leave a letter encouraging her to get some rest and keep her spirits up.
Nilou:
She'll be better soon, and then we can celebrate together at the theater!
Paimon:
It's all thanks to you and Nilou that we managed to save Dunyarzad!
Nilou:
You're way too modest! Just now, I actually felt really self-conscious when Paimon talked about us in the same breath.
Nilou:
Compared to you, I really didn't do much at all.
Nilou:
Hehe, anyway, all that aside, are you thinking about coming to our event?
Paimon:
Paimon thinks it'll be a great time... What do you think, Traveler?
Nilou:
Alright, then let's head to the theater...
Nilou:
—Wait, I completely forgot about this pile of stuff!
You and Paimon both notice that there's a huge batch of goods next to Nilou...
Traveler:
Did you run into any trouble after your dance?
Nilou:
You mean when I danced at the square right in front of the Akademiya? Hehe, not a single person came after me. I left really easily.
Nilou:
After that, no one came to the theater to scold me, either. We actually gained many new customers... And, they were all Akademiya students.
Nilou:
From what I can tell, in the past, if a student were to put off their studies to watch a show or dance, they'd be called foolish and irresponsible.
Nilou:
But now, it seems like this attitude is changing. People are starting to believe that engaging with the arts can help them balance their moods, and through that, improve their research efficiency at work.
Nilou:
Anyway, it seems like people have to personally experience something to gain a good understanding of it.
Paimon:
They should thank us for opening their eyes!
Traveler:
Hopefully, they'll appreciate the arts more.
Nilou:
That'll probably take some time... They're still droning on and on about "experimentation" and "proof." Will they really gain more appreciation for the arts if they continue to think of everything like that?
Paimon:
Whoa! Did you buy all of this, Nilou!?
Nilou:
Just one box. The rest were given to me. I really don't know how it came to this much...
Paimon:
That's way too many freebies! Many vendors give out samples for free, but Paimon's never seen this much...
Nilou:
All I know is that whenever I start chatting with people, my hands would get more and more full until I can't hold everything anymore. This seems to happen every time...
Nilou:
I was planning on making a few trips to bring everything back, before continuing on with my shopping... but I don't think I'll have the time.
Paimon:
So this isn't even all of it!?
Traveler:
Let me help you.
Nilou:
A—Are you sure?
Paimon:
Of course! Carrying stuff is a piece of cake for him. Right, Traveler?
Nilou:
Ahh, I'm so sorry to trouble you like this... I meant to invite you to our celebration, but now, you're helping me instead...
Nilou:
Well, let's hurry up and grab the last few things, so we can get back to the theater.
Collect the purchased goods with Nilou
Jut:
Oh, well if it isn't Nilou!
Nilou:
Greetings, Mr. Jut! Do you still have any food that's ready-to-go?
Jut:
Of course I do! I've heard that Zubayr Theater is hosting a celebration event, so I reserved some food for you in advance.
Jut:
Although, it looks like you're gonna need two more portions, haha.
Nilou:
Ah, please allow me to introduce them! This is Traveler, a very experienced adventurer.
Nilou:
And this is Paimon, his super reliable guide and helper.
Paimon:
Nonono, Paimon is—! ...Hold on, she got it completely right! Look, Traveler, she introduced Paimon correctly!
Jut:
Hahaha, don't underestimate Nilou! She always remembers every last little detail about everyone, even if it sounds completely trivial.
Jut:
She's also very brave. Just a little while ago, she saved my precious spices from the jaws of a Sumpter Beast!
Nilou:
Ahh, don't think anything of it! I just help out when I can because everyone else takes such good care of me.
Nilou:
Anyway, sorry to get off topic, we're in a bit of a hurry! Mr. Jut, did you say you didn't reserve enough food?
Jut:
Haha, I was joking! Anyone who runs a business knows to keep some extra stock. After all, orders get changed all the time.
Jut:
Oh, that reminds me, it seems that these friends of yours aren't from here. Have they ever tried any delicious Tahchin?
Nilou:
Ooh, what a fantastic idea! Mr. Jut, did you bake a batch recently?
Nilou:
Tahchin is a mixture of rice and meat that's baked into a cake-like shape. Mr. Jut adds special spices into his!
Nilou:
Its aroma is just so wonderfully delicious! If you ever see kids crowding all around Mr. Jut's place, you'd know he's baking up a storm.
Jut:
Hahaha, but is it really just for the kids? Don't you often follow them in, too?
Nilou:
I—I just can't help myself...
Paimon:
We're two peas in a pod! Who doesn't enjoy some good food?
Jut:
Wait here, I'll bring some over.
Everyone enjoys piping-hot Tahchin together.
Nilou:
Mmmmm...
Paimon:
Whoa, what a dish! It's sweet and sour and full of deliciousness! Paimon can't eat it fast enough!
Traveler:
Typical Paimon.
Nilou:
No matter how many times I eat it, it's still so delicious!
Jut:
Haha, I wouldn't have offered it as a treat if I wasn't confident in the taste!
Jut:
I baked a lot just now, and it's all packaged and ready for you to take back to the theater.
Nilou:
You made so much! Is it really okay to take them all...
Jut:
It was nothin'! Making one serving or one hundred servings is all the same to me. If anything, I should be thanking you for helping me clear my inventory.
Traveler:
We should pay you, at least.
Jut:
Don't worry about it! What kind of person would I be if I made you pay for a treat?
Jut:
Haha, make sure you got everything!
Jut:
Feel free to come back anytime.
Paimon:
...Paimon's starting to understand how you got so many things.
Nilou:
Y—Yeah... Everyone has their own way with words, and it's really hard to say no...
Nilou:
Let's go to the next store.
Collect another batch of goods with Nilou
Afshin:
Nilou, good timing! I have the textiles you ordered.
Afshin:
If you took any longer, the Sumpter Beasts might've gobbled them up.
Nilou:
You and your jokes! Sumpter Beasts won't eat those kinds of things, Mr. Afshin.
Paimon:
Jut said that some Sumpter Beasts ate his spices. Were they yours?
Afshin:
Oh, uh, haha... Yeah, really sorry about that. Nilou, if it weren't for you, I would've lost half of my profits that month.
Nilou:
Trying to pull anything out of a Sumpter Beast's mouth is like playing a game of tug-of-war...
Paimon:
So they really do eat anything, huh.
Paimon:
Eh? What's that supposed to mean!
Afshin:
Hahaha, come now. You know, Sumpter Beasts sometimes eat not because they're hungry, but because they like gnawing on things.
Afshin:
The textiles you ordered are highly durable and woven from the finest thread.
Afshin:
So, even if a Sumpter Beast got snacky, it'd still have to chomp on it for a full day.
Paimon:
...You've tested this before?
Afshin:
But of course! How else could I be so trustworthy? ...Well, that one time was an accident.
Afshin:
I wouldn't dare experiment with such a precious product.
Paimon:
True, it does sound like some good fabric...
Afshin:
Oho, have I piqued your interest? If you want to buy some, now's a good time: Buy two bolts and get 20% off!
Paimon:
Ooh, that's a pretty good discount. What do you think, Traveler?
Nilou:
No thanks, Mr. Afshin. You can't use that kind of tactic on her. Look, you've already sucked her in.
Paimon:
Uh... Tactic? So you mean, everything he just said to Paimon was a lie?
Nilou:
Ah, I wouldn't go that far... It's just that Mr. Afshin is really good at spinning stories. A word from him, and you'll find yourself buying things you don't actually need.
Nilou:
Mr. Zubayr gave me a huge lecture the last time I bought too many things...
Traveler:
Vendors shouldn't use manipulative tactics.
Afshin:
C'mon, don't look at me like that... All she got was a talking-to from Zubayr, while I was nearly fed head-first to the Sumpter Beasts.
Afshin:
My philosophy is that stories give value to merchandise. That's why my business started with such a boom.
Afshin:
Our Nilou here is an extraordinarily good listener. Back then, she believed anything I said.
Afshin:
After a while, I began to feel guilty selling things to her because of how happy she looked... Though she enjoyed the stories and I the Mora, I knew she didn't need to buy that much...
Afshin:
Anyway, since then, I've come to realize two things: One, that stories should just be a means instead of an end, and two, that there's more to business than just selling goods.
Nilou:
It's okay, we're all friends now. There's no need to dig up the past.
Afshin:
Hmm, that reminds me... Some of the goods from my latest shipment aren't in the best condition.
Afshin:
They're fine for general use, but my customers have high standards, and I don't have the time or resources to find new buyers right now.
Afshin:
Nilou, why don't you take them?
Nilou:
Huh? No no no no, I can't do that...
Afshin:
Just think of it as a favor for me, alright? The theater can use them for props and whatnot.
Afshin:
It costs me Mora to store or ship, so I'm just losing money every day continuing to hold on to them.
Nilou:
Even so, let me buy them at market value.
Afshin:
Nah, these goods are hard movers. Besides, if I let you pay, wouldn't it mean that I'm just using stories to sell my goods again?
Afshin:
Just take them. If you really feel that bad about it, give me some theater tickets later.
Afshin:
Oh yeah, you should also take some while you're at it. Adventurers are always in need of materials, right?
Paimon:
Wow, even we get a share of this...?
Afshin:
Hurry and take it. Just looking at it all is giving me a headache. Haha, thanks for the huge favor.
Nilou:
There's still one more store. Are you alright holding onto that much stuff?
Nilou:
Paimon, why don't you lend a hand? He must be tired.
Paimon:
I—If Paimon were to refuse...
Paimon:
Would you then think less of Paimon than even a Sumpter Beast?
Collect the last goods with Nilou
Hushang:
About time, Nilou! Farhad here was snooping around your props!
Farhad:
Please, I was only looking at them to get a better idea of what your new show may be about.
Hushang:
Wouldn't spoiling yourself just ruin all the fun?
Nilou:
Yeah, please wait for our official performance!
Hushang:
Hmm, these two look familiar. I think I've seen them before...
Hushang:
Weren't they at the Sabzeruz Festival?
Nilou:
Yeah, and they're coming to today's celebration, too.
Hushang:
The more folks the merrier! I was actually just talking to Farhad about also stopping by tonight.
Nilou:
Oh yes, please do! I'm sure Ms. Rekhar and Miss Najia would also love to have a chat with the two of you.
Hushang:
We even prepared a small gift — let me show it to you. Ta-da, it's a flower wreath!
Hushang:
I really think we should wear some of these to give the event a more celebratory feel.
Nilou:
Wow, it's beautiful! Did you make it?
Hushang:
Farhad did most of the work. What a surprise, eh? He actually knows a lot about crafts.
Paimon:
That is pretty surprising...
Farhad:
Hey, why can't I have a little side hobby? I worked really hard on that!
Hushang:
I know, I know, I watched you make it. I wasn't making fun of you.
Hushang:
Alright, why don't you also try some on? We've got some wreaths in your size.
Nilou:
It fits perfectly.
Paimon:
They're so pretty! Is there one that Paimon can wear?
Farhad:
Unfortunately, we already gave out all the child-sized ones. I wasn't expecting the theater to invite such a fascinating guest.
Paimon:
"Fascinating"...? That sounds kinda weird, but Paimon will let it slide.
Farhad:
Oh, you all sure got a lot of stuff there. Let me help you carry some.
Farhad:
I'm a porter by trade, so this is what I'm best at.
Paimon:
That'd be great! Please and thank you!
Paimon:
But we have a pro now...
Nilou:
Thanks for the help, Mr. Farhad, but let me make one thing clear first: Don't try to ask about what's in the new show.
Nilou:
Otherwise, I may not be able to hold back Mr. Zubayr this time.
Hushang:
Hahaha, you're so obvious that even Nilou saw right through you!
Farhad:
Shut it!
Farhad:
Fine! It's not like I want to get on his bad side, either.
Farhad:
Including Hushang's things, though, we'll each need to carry a box if we want to move everything in one trip. Even my strength has its limits.
Nilou:
Paimon looks like she doesn't want to, so I'll carry a little extra. Hehe, although I may not appear super strong at first glance, I actually do a lot of strength training on the regular.
Nilou:
Strength and balance are both really important for a dancer!
Paimon:
No, no, let Paimon! Paimon will help carry things!
Paimon:
The Traveler's right. Paimon shouldn't freeload...
Paimon:
*pant* *pant*
Paimon:
Paimon can't fly anymore...!
Nilou:
Are you okay, Paimon?
Paimon:
Paimon's good to keep going! But Paimon now understands when people say there's no such thing as a free lunch!
Go back to the theater with Nilou
Farhad:
Phew, that sure was a lot of stuff. Looking forward to the event later!
Nilou:
Thank you, Mr. Farhad.
Paimon:
Thank you, Sumpter Man...
Traveler:
Thank you, Paimon.
Paimon:
Phew... Paimon's definitely going to eat it all back later!
Farhad:
Alright, I'll leave you all to it.
Nilou:
See ya.
Nilou:
Good thing we had Mr. Farhad with us, or else that would've taken way longer.
Nilou:
Of course, because everyone's working here together.
Nilou:
We're all like neighbors, so we're always helping each other out. It's easy to forget that everyone's running a business.
Paimon:
With this many freebies being thrown at you, you probably don't need to work...
Nilou:
Hehe, I felt so guilty at first, like I always owed someone something. I was always thinking of ways to repay others.
Nilou:
Later on, I realized that it's actually like what Mr. Afshin said — by taking the freebies, I was helping everyone out and saving them money.
Nilou:
When you order the wrong item or make too much of something, sometimes the best way to maximize the value of those goods is to give them away.
Nilou:
That's why there's no need to stress over the freebies. All of us repay others by helping them when they need it.
Paimon:
Oh, that actually makes a lot of sense!
Nilou:
This has become our norm, and no one keeps track of the back and forth anymore.
Nilou:
So really, don't worry about it.
Nilou:
Alright, I have to bring all of this to Mr. Zubayr and do a little bit of prep.
Nilou:
Feel free to hang out here for a bit. It'd be nice if you could also get to know some other people at the theater!
Traveler:
You sure you don't need any help?
Nilou:
Nope. Mr. Zubayr's really on top of everything.
Nilou:
You two are our guests, so please just relax and look forward to the celebration.
Paimon:
Wow, the atmosphere here is so nice...
Paimon:
Let's take a break, and immerse ourselves in this warmth!
Talk to the members of the theater
Rekhar:
Hey there. I saw you two helping Nilou move some stuff.
Rekhar:
Are you two also here for the celebration event?
Paimon:
You got it!
Rekhar:
My name is Rekhar. Najia and I are this theater's prop engineers. I also help out with some other tasks, like housekeeping.
Rekhar:
The little ones causing a ruckus are my children, Sohrin and Abhi. I hope they aren't bothering you.
Rekhar:
They always get really excited every time we hold a celebration event.
Rekhar:
Yes, they are. Everyone here takes great care of them.
Rekhar:
There's good work here, the pay's always on time, and Nilou and the others will often volunteer to play with the kids...
Rekhar:
I'm quite content with this current way of life.
Paimon:
Um, do you mean your life wasn't nearly as good before?
Traveler:
Paimon...
Rekhar:
It's alright, it's all water under the bridge now.
Rekhar:
My husband and I were both adventurers, but he passed away from an accident.
Rekhar:
Material struggles can always be overcome, but ever since then, I haven't been able to spend much of my energy on anything else...
Rekhar:
But I still consider myself lucky. Mr. Zubayr has helped me a lot, and the atmosphere here is tolerant and kind.
Paimon:
Sorry for bringing up such sad memories...
Rekhar:
Oh, it's alright, I don't mind.
Rekhar:
Once the event starts, you'll be able to see for yourself the kind of atmosphere I was talking about.
Talk to the members of the theater
Paimon:
Hey there!
Khasani:
Hm... Ah, a newcomer.
Khasani:
Doesn't look too bright.
Paimon:
Hey! Talk about judging a book by its cover!
Khasani:
You, on the other hand... Hmm, you're a special one.
Khasani:
How would you describe the concept of "art"?
Khasani:
Mere curiosity, is all. It makes no difference whether you answer or not.
Khasani:
So that's what you think, huh...
Khasani:
Unremarkable. Better than an average person's thoughts, but nothing exceptional.
Khasani:
Is art a product that we create and bring forth, or is it a naturally existing resource?
Khasani:
I, for one, believe it to be the latter.
Paimon:
Uhh, Paimon doesn't follow...
Khasani:
I've been staying here for a long time. On occasion, I'd assist them in penning lines of dialogue, but most of my time, I just stand back and watch.
Khasani:
I prefer to abstain from writing, as it spoils the viewing experience.
Khasani:
The existence of the theater, of Nilou, and of humanity itself... All of these can be considered as forms of art. It is not some intangible construct beyond the horizon.
Paimon:
How does that have anything to do with us?
Khasani:
Let me ask you this: What do you think is the meaning of art?
Khasani:
Haha, I suppose that question was a little too difficult for you.
Khasani:
To chance upon a spark of inspiration, I have been closely observing you, the players on the stage, and those watching in the audience.
Khasani:
Art is already all around us.
Talk to the members of the theater
Paimon:
Hello!
Inayah:
Wh—Wha!?
Inayah:
Who are you? You can't just go on the stage as you please.
Inayah:
Ah, I see... Sorry for my overreaction.
Inayah:
I'm just, uh... making a prop. No time for chit-chat.
Paimon:
Is that embroidery?
Inayah:
No... Well, yes, but not really. It's a prop.
Inayah:
It's just, uhh, some fabric. An ordinary piece of fabric that will be used in a show.
Inayah:
Sorry, I really do need to focus and start working on it.
Paimon:
What an oddball. Is prop-making something to be that jumpy about?
Paimon:
Oh well, it's none of our business.
Talk with Nilou and wait for the event to begin
Paimon:
Look, Nilou's back!
Paimon:
Let's meet up with her. The event's probably about to start!
Nilou:
Sorry for the wait! Preparations for the celebration are finally done.
Nilou:
I'll call everyone over, and then we can start.
Paimon:
Let us give you a hand!
Nilou:
Hee-hee, thank you.
Everyone gathers together, and the event finally starts. Participants prepare to exchange their presents.
Paimon:
Maybe we really should have prepared a gift. Then we could also be a part of the exchange!
Paimon:
As it is, all we can do is wait and watch...
Inayah:
Umm... Maybe we shouldn't do this after all?
Inayah:
I didn't do that great of a job, and who would even like it?
Nilou:
Don't think like that! Remember our promise? We're going to give everyone a pleasant surprise.
Nilou:
And besides, you've never attended a celebration event before, so this will be a great opportunity. Everyone will love you!
Inayah:
I'm still... not really sure about this...
Nilou:
There's nothing to be worried about! Just take a step forward, and give yourself a chance.
Nilou:
There aren't any scary people here, right?
Inayah:
Right...
Nilou:
Hmm, alright, maybe this will help.
Nilou:
Everyone, over here! Inayah has something great to tell you all!
Inayah:
W—Wait, wait!
Inayah:
I've already said that I'm not ready yet... Agh, what should I say...
Nilou:
Take it easy and relax. Deep breath, in and out. Once you've taken a long exhale, calmly tell everyone what you want to say.
Nilou:
If you don't say anything, then all the hard work we've put into embroidery practice would have gone to waste.
Inayah:
Using it as a gift, though? It really isn't that good...
Paimon:
So when Inayah was talking about making a prop, she was actually preparing a present.
Paimon:
Yeah, it feels like she still doesn't really see herself as part of this community.
Paimon:
But it looks like Nilou's trying to ease her through.
Nilou:
Actually, Inayah had prepared a special present for everyone before this celebration kicked off.
Sohrin:
Woohoo!
Abhi:
We're gonna get our first present from Miss Inayah!
Sheikh Zubayr:
Pipe down. The louder you all are, the more nervous she'll become.
Sheikh Zubayr:
You've worked on it for so long, so have some confidence. Don't be afraid.
Paimon:
You've got this!
Inayah:
...
Sharif:
Is Mr. Zubayr here?
A stern-looking researcher shows himself in the audience.
Sharif:
Sheikh Zubayr, this is an urgent notice from the Akademiya. This celebration — or whatever it is — must stop at once.
Paimon:
What a condescending guy... What's his deal?
Everyone follows Sheikh Zubayr to the space below the theater.
Sharif:
Since Zubayr Theater has long violated the Akademiya's policies and orders, we have decided to demolish it.
Sharif:
As its manager, you must halt all operations and dismiss all staff members within thirty days, after which you will report to the Akademiya for further punishment.
Nilou:
Why...? Why force us to do this all of a sudden?
Sharif:
Little girl, this is not the first time you've been issued a warning.
Sheikh Zubayr:
I didn't hear anything about demolition the last time I asked, and now I suddenly only have thirty days?
Sheikh Zubayr:
We have more shows planned, but it's impossible to do anything in just thirty days. How am I supposed to explain this to my customers and staff?
Sharif:
That issue is of no concern to me, Mr. Zubayr.
Sharif:
You seem to understand the situation quite clearly. Perhaps you can reflect on the reasons why you have failed to prepare for the scenario in advance.
Paimon:
...Demolition? Why do they wanna demolish this place?
Nilou:
The Akademiya has never liked us, and they've never respected our work. To them, what we do is all a waste of time.
Nilou:
This isn't the first time they've come by. They had asked us several times in the past to improve the quality of our performances by only putting on shows they consider to be sufficiently intellectual.
Nilou:
But our audience isn't the Akademiya — it's the people of the Grand Bazaar.
Nilou:
If our shows are too difficult to understand or too removed from everyday life, nobody would watch them anymore...
Nilou:
Changing our content would not only mean turning our backs on our vision, it would also directly lead to the loss of our livelihoods.
Nilou:
Yeah... The theater is very important to each and every one of us.
Paimon:
The way they're doing things is so scummy!
Nilou:
But... I also don't know how we can stop them.
Sharif:
I do not wish to explain everything again from the beginning. Time is of the essence, so you should act with haste instead of asking frivolous questions.
Sheikh Zubayr:
But none of us plan to accept this. Such an abrupt notice is contrary to established policy.
Sharif:
Ask whomever you will — the answer will remain the same. We have already given you sufficient notice.
Inayah:
Enough.
Inayah:
Does your audacity know no limits, Father!?
Paimon:
Huh? Father? They're family!?
Inayah:
What Akademiya? This is all because you don't like Zubayr Theater. You're just using the Akademiya's name to threaten us!
Inayah:
Let me tell you: Even if you manage to tear down this place, nothing is going to change.
Inayah:
You've always been awful, but even I never thought my father would sink this low!
Sharif:
This is strictly business. It has nothing to do with where you are, what you do...
Sharif:
...Or what you think.
Sharif:
I hope you all have not been irrevocably blinded by folly. I will not waste more time on pointless arguments.
Sharif:
Wrap everything up and make preparations to shut down at once.
Inayah:
...
Inayah:
Why is he always like that!?
Sheikh Zubayr:
This is quite the misfortune, but there's nothing we can do.
Sheikh Zubayr:
That's it for today, everyone. Let's clean up.
Sheikh Zubayr:
I'll go talk to them again tomorrow. *sigh* The storms that come out of the blue are always the hardest to deal with.
Talk with Nilou about the current situation
Nilou:
Sorry, I invited you thinking this was going to be a happy occasion. I didn't know that things would turn out like this...
Paimon:
There's no need to apologize, Nilou! No one could've seen this coming. *sigh* Paimon just wishes she could've at least gotten to the food...
Paimon:
Is what that guy said true? The Akademiya has already given you many warnings?
Nilou:
Yeah, I guess you could say that. They've always seen us as being meaningless.
Nilou:
Knowledge is king in Sumeru, and their pursuit of it leaves no room for the arts.
Nilou:
But if that's all it is, there's also no reason to go so far as to demolish the theater.
Traveler:
So it really has something to do with Inayah.
Nilou:
After Inayah ran away from home, I brought her here, to Zubayr Theater.
Nilou:
She rarely talks about her family. All I know is that she didn't get along with them.
Nilou:
I never expected it to blow up like this...
Paimon:
If you did nothing wrong, then there's no reason to listen to the Akademiya, right?
Traveler:
I can ask Nahida to lend a hand.
Nilou:
Nahida... Ah!? You mean, Lesser Lord Kusanali!?
Paimon:
She'd probably help if she knew what was going on. No matter how nasty the Akademiya could get, surely they can't win against Lesser Lord Kusanali!
Nilou:
Nononono, I wasn't doubting her ability... I just feel like we shouldn't bother her with such a trivial problem.
Nilou:
Plus, if the Dendro Archon were to intervene... Then, it wouldn't feel like our victory was earned.
Paimon:
That's true...
Paimon:
Who cares, let's just take them in a fight!
Paimon:
That's true...
Nilou:
I'll try to think of something. We can't just let everyone suffer in a perpetual state of fear and uncertainty.
Nilou:
What to do, what to do...
Paimon:
Can you pretend to shut down, but secretly continue to hold your shows somewhere else?
Paimon:
Or we could go through a list of customers, and try to see if anyone in there might be willing to help out... Ugh, that also doesn't sound like it'll work.
Nilou:
A debate? Hmm... Well, scholars do love to use them to solve their problems, but... how would that work in this case?
Paimon:
Oh, if we can prove to Inayah's father that the Akademiya's position doesn't hold water, then they won't have a reason to demolish the theater!
Nilou:
I see. Defeating him in a debate...
Nilou:
It's a good idea, but which one of us could hope to win against a researcher...?
After a moment's consideration, both you and Paimon look back.
Nilou:
Huh? Me?
Nilou:
Nonono, I'm the literal worst at arguments.
Nilou:
I can't debate...
Paimon:
Nilou, you are only so stressed out right now because you care so much about protecting the theater!
Nilou:
I...
Nilou:
This theater holds a special meaning in all of our hearts — it's irreplaceable.
Nilou:
But I just don't know... Can I really take on such a huge responsibility?
Paimon:
Paimon will help, too! You'll feel a lot more confident after doing some prep work. Believe in yourself!
Nilou:
Thanks, you two.
Nilou:
Alright, I've decided!
Nilou:
Even though I may fail, I'll do my very best for everyone's sake!
Paimon:
That's our Nilou! We're rooting for you!
Nilou:
Okay, let's head back and tell everyone what we came up with.
With your encouragement, Nilou decided to debate with the Akademiya scholar about the demolition of the theatre. Thus, she needs to collect a lot of information.
Gather everybody and get the situation straight
Everyone gathers together. After hearing Nilou's thoughts...
Sheikh Zubayr:
Trying to best the Akademiya in a debate is attempting the impossible.
Sheikh Zubayr:
If you really want to try, I won't stop you. It's not like our situation can get any worse.
Rekhar:
I don't think it's entirely hopeless. To Sharif, Nilou's approach will come off as naive, but that kind of frankness is exactly what they lack the most.
Rekhar:
Things might turn out differently from what you expect.
Khasani:
I am in favor of such a romantic feat. No playwright will turn down a compelling underdog story.
Kourosh:
Sure, in fiction, but I'm not sure how well that will translate to reality...
Kourosh:
I—I'm not saying that I don't support you, Nilou. If you need my help, just say the word!
Kourosh:
Anything is better than just standing aside and watching the theater get demolished.
Najia:
I'm also pitching in. Let's show the Akademiya that we have some fight in us!
Nilou:
Thank you, everyone. I feel a lot less nervous with your support!
Inayah:
Not to rain on your parade, but my father is a real hard guy to deal with.
Inayah:
He is erudite, meticulous, demanding, and exceedingly familiar with rigorous logic. It'll be extremely difficult to beat him in a debate.
Inayah:
You all already knew that, but you just didn't want to hurt Nilou's feelings.
Inayah:
When all's said and done, aren't you hurting her just the same?
Sheikh Zubayr:
That's enough, Inayah. Hehe...
Inayah:
...
Inayah:
Sorry, I ruined the mood.
Inayah:
I just can't force myself to expect a positive outcome. Nilou shouldn't have to push herself for the sake of an impossible goal.
Paimon:
Yeah! It's way too early to give up.
Nilou:
You're right, Inayah.
Nilou:
We're up against the Akademiya. Everyone knows that they're very powerful. Being skeptical might actually be the more normal response.
Nilou:
But I still want to try. I'm reluctant to just let Zubayr Theater go.
Nilou:
And it's not just me — I think everyone else here feels the same way. If we're unhappy, we should speak up and let our voices be heard.
Nilou:
Say what's on your mind, and do what you think should be done. If we fail after that, then at least we won't have any regrets.
Nilou:
I mean... after all, the only thing we can control right now is our choice at this very moment.
Inayah:
...I understand what you're trying to say. I also have my own intense feelings of anger and regret.
Nilou:
Then, could I trouble you to tell your father about our plan for a debate?
Nilou:
You can still get in touch with your family, right?
Inayah:
Yes, I can.
Nilou:
Then, please help us pass on my request. I've never participated in a debate, and truth be told, I'm still not really confident in myself.
Nilou:
But since we've decided on a debate, I'll do my best to prepare for it. I'll gather everyone's thoughts and let them be known to all during the debate.
Nilou:
I by myself definitely don't have enough wisdom to beat your father, but what about the entire theater combined? Then we should have a chance, right?
Inayah:
...Right.
Sohrin:
That's right, Miss Nilou!
Abhi:
Beat the bad guy! Justice will prevail!
Sohrin:
Make him eat dirt!
Nilou:
Hee-hee, you two, we aren't getting into a fight.
Nilou:
But thank you for your encouraging words. I'll do my best!
Paimon:
Well said back there, Nilou!
Nilou:
I felt that I might have said a bit too much...
Nilou:
Anyway, we better start preparing now. First, let's see what everyone thinks about the situation.
Paimon:
Alright, time to poll everyone's thoughts!
Collect the thoughts of theater members
Rekhar:
I didn't expect you all to challenge the Akademiya.
Rekhar:
That reminded me of my younger years... Back then, I feared nothing and no one, and I was always charging into the most dangerous of places.
Rekhar:
I can't do things like that anymore, but those were some of the best times of my life.
Nilou:
Sorry... If the theater really ends up getting demolished, then you, Sohrin, and Abhi will all...
Rekhar:
It's alright. There's no need to think such heavy thoughts. Even if the building gets demolished, its people will still all be here.
Rekhar:
Have faith in the resilience of an adventurer. We can always figure something out.
Nilou:
But won't you have regrets if things just come to an abrupt end? It'd be like when you were forced to stop adventuring...
Rekhar:
Ah, so that's what you were worrying about.
Rekhar:
Relax, I've had a lot of experience with regret. Things are painful at first, but as they say, time heals all wounds.
Rekhar:
Look at us now: Sohrin and Abhi are happy, and Sohrin has also just passed his theater exam. He can start acting soon.
Rekhar:
He was thrilled because he can soon perform on the same stage as you.
Rekhar:
We wouldn't be here if it weren't for our past struggles. And would Sohrin have become a happier person? That's hard to say.
Paimon:
Are you... trying to make us feel better?
Rekhar:
Yes, but I truly do mean what I say. Being here at the theater has taught me an important lesson.
Rekhar:
The most important thing about an experience is how you choose to interpret it.
Rekhar:
I can choose to believe that my life ended with my husband's death, or I can choose to believe that it was a blessing in disguise for Sohrin and Abhi.
Rekhar:
Similarly, even if this theater disappears, a new beginning might just be around the corner.
Rekhar:
"Good" and "bad" are all human-made concepts. It all depends on how we choose to see things.
Nilou:
You have a point...
Rekhar:
Nilou, I know how important Zubayr Theater is to you.
Rekhar:
But you don't have to be so nervous — we're all here with you. The theater won't go down so easily.
Nilou:
Thank you, Ms. Rekhar.
Rekhar:
No need to thank me. If anything, you inspired me with your bravery. You might have what it takes to become an excellent adventurer.
Nilou:
Y—You're too kind...
Nilou:
Alright, I gotta cheer up! I can't waste everyone's words of encouragement!
Nilou:
Haaah, I feel a lot better.
Rekhar:
Good. My children and I will be cheering you on at the debate.
Collect the thoughts of theater members
Paimon:
Paimon doesn't really wanna talk to him...
Khasani:
So you've already developed some prejudices against me. And to think, I was just about to put forward a suggestion...
Paimon:
Ooh, Paimon will listen to that!
Khasani:
Although, I know not if you have a new answer to my previous question. Now seems like an appropriate time to revisit it.
Khasani:
What do you think is the meaning of art?
Paimon:
Ugh... This again?
Nilou:
We probably do need to tackle this question if we want to prove the value of the arts.
Nilou:
I don't know how to explain it, but all I know is that when my performance makes the audience happy, I also become very happy.
Nilou:
Does that count as a meaning?
Paimon:
You answered him so seriously! Careful, Nilou, this guy's ramblings never make any sense.
Khasani:
No, no, Nilou's answer far surpasses yours, and it is close to my own.
Khasani:
The meaning of art comes not from its creators, but from its audience.
Khasani:
In other words, only art that can be appreciated by others will impart its essence and value upon the minds of its audience.
Khasani:
This is something that the Akademiya can never understand.
Traveler:
You seem to have many stories of your own.
Khasani:
I once pursued the mastery of art, much like how a researcher would chase wisdom and knowledge.
Khasani:
However, the more of a connoisseur I became, the less I felt I understood. I began to question what it truly meant for art to be "understood" at all.
Khasani:
I knew that the most sophisticated works are often the least appreciated, and yet somehow, that provided me with little solace.
Khasani:
I remained ever perplexed about this conundrum until I visited this theater, and watched one of Nilou's performances.
Paimon:
It was that life-changing...?
Khasani:
Everyone here had a joyous part in the overall experience. The actors upon the stage basked in the love of their audience, while those in the house immersed themselves in the wondrous ambiance.
Khasani:
In all honesty, from a purely critical point of view, the performances here are exceedingly average.
Nilou:
Hey, don't say something like that...
Khasani:
But what bewildered me was how despite the performances' middling quality, they captivated their whole audience... they captivated even me.
Khasani:
I realized then that I had walked the wrong road. The mastery of art was never what I truly wanted.
Khasani:
I left the so-called frontiers of artistic research and came to this theater, for this is where I can finally find what I seek.
Khasani:
Art will no longer be a castle in the sky. Whether it be inspiring or entertaining, art must be appreciated by others to confer value.
Khasani:
If art cannot accomplish that, then it is meaningless.
Nilou:
When you put it that way...
Nilou:
Mr. Zubayr and I refused to follow the Akademiya's orders to change our shows for a similar reason.
Nilou:
To put it simply, we were afraid that our shows would lose their meaning if people couldn't understand them...
Khasani:
I once stood in the spotlight, but I relinquished fame and acclaim for the freedom I enjoy today.
Khasani:
I care not for where my feet may take me next, but Nilou, you need to remember one thing.
Khasani:
You already stand upon the finest stage there is, and that is a rare gift that should never be taken for granted.
Khasani:
You cannot give it up, not even to the Akademiya.
Nilou:
I understand. Thank you for your words of encouragement, Mr. Khasani.
Khasani:
Dust the cobwebs away from the eyes of those scholars.
Paimon:
He really seemed to care a lot about the theater...
Nilou:
Once you get to know him, you'll realize that he's actually a big softie at heart. He'll even help out with furniture repair and painting the stage!
Paimon:
Wow, Paimon didn't think he had that in him at all!
Collect the thoughts of theater members
Nilou:
Mr. Zubayr, we're trying to put together a list of arguments that might be useful. Any ideas?
Sheikh Zubayr:
It won't be difficult to explain our position. They're in the wrong, and they know it!
Sheikh Zubayr:
I have meticulously managed this theater's affairs for years, and I have abided by every procedure and obtained every permit.
Sheikh Zubayr:
I did all of that to protect ourselves if something like this were to occur. I didn't expect them to disregard the rules altogether...
Traveler:
This might have something to do with Inayah.
Sheikh Zubayr:
Yes, I know. But anyone who's staying at the theater is one of us.
Sheikh Zubayr:
If I can't even protect the members of the theater from outside pressure, then I have failed in my duty as a manager.
Sheikh Zubayr:
In summary, you need sufficient confidence and strict adherence to the rules. At least for now, they don't have the authority to demolish the theater.
Sheikh Zubayr:
As long as you double down on that point and force them to concede it, you'll gain an advantage.
Nilou:
Alright, got it!
Sheikh Zubayr:
*sigh* I've seen many situations like this before. The Akademiya sure likes to get its nose into everyone's business...
Sheikh Zubayr:
While you prepare for the debate, I will also prepare the theater for the potential aftermath. It's best to prepare for the worst outcome.
Sheikh Zubayr:
Once you're done chatting, do me a favor and tell our customers that we're canceling all of our shows.
Paimon:
Do we really have to...?
Sheikh Zubayr:
Right now, no one's in the right frame of mind to perform. I have to consider both our staff and our customers. This is the only way.
Sheikh Zubayr:
...Nilou, you are incredible.
Sheikh Zubayr:
With your talent and youth, you had the least to lose out of all of us. And yet, you were still the first to take a stand.
Nilou:
I've never thought about leaving your theater, Mr. Zubayr. I truly love this place, and I want to keep dancing here.
Nilou:
I also want to keep dancing with everyone else.
Sheikh Zubayr:
You're becoming more and more like her...
Sheikh Zubayr:
Do your best. We'll do all that we can, and leave the rest to fate.
Paimon:
"Her"?
Nilou:
My teacher. She was an excellent dancer, but she's retired now.
Nilou:
If we have time later, I'd be happy to tell you more about her.
Inform customers of the shows being canceled
Farhad:
You're here! Is the theater actually closing!?
Hushang:
He's been worried sick for a while now. He wouldn't stop talking the whole way back.
Farhad:
H—Hey, you too!
Jut:
What exactly happened? Did someone come down from the Akademiya?
Nilou:
Yes. He told us that we have to shut down the theater within thirty days, and that it's going to be demolished...
Farhad:
What the heck!? That came with no warning!
Afshin:
*sigh* They're messing with us again.
Farhad:
Don't tell me you'll have to listen to him?
Hushang:
C'mon, you know the answer to that.
Farhad:
Yeah, it IS a direct order from the Akademiya...
Nilou:
There's no need to worry, though. I'm preparing for a public debate with the Akademiya.
Nilou:
If I win, we might be able to overturn things and change their minds.
Jut:
Really? That's terrific. You have my full support, no doubt about that.
Afshin:
Mine too! So, what was their excuse, anyway? They still not a fan of the theater's programs?
Nilou:
Yeah, something like that...
Farhad:
Good thing they have the power to make rash decisions about things they don't even understand, huh?
Hushang:
Yeah, they need to touch more grass, not books.
Afshin:
Exactly. They want to look down on us? Haha, we'll look down on them first!
Jut:
Don't worry, everyone here has your back. The Akademiya's recklessness won't get them any praise.
Farhad:
Right. They might think that some forms of knowledge are more valuable than others, but everyone can equally appreciate art.
Farhad:
If they don't believe that, send 'em my way. I got them beat on this subject.
Hushang:
Maybe you can prepare some questions on the details of dance performance to make things harder for them at the debate?
Nilou:
Hmm... Sounds like a good idea. Maybe that's something I should do.
Farhad:
Ignore him — he's joking. Just do things your way.
Farhad:
No matter what, we will always support you.
Nilou:
Thank you all so much! Your understanding and support make me feel a lot better.
Jut:
There are always more solutions than problems. If you need help during the debate, just shout and the entire Grand Bazaar will be at your beck and call.
Afshin:
Heh, gotta show them who has the people's support!
Go back to the theater
Nilou:
Abhi, have you seen Miss Inayah?
Abhi:
No, Miss Nilou! Miss Inayah isn't back yet.
Paimon:
Wasn't she just passing on a message? Does she really need this much time?
Traveler:
Could she have started arguing with her father again?
Nilou:
...
Nilou:
Ahhhh... Oh no.
Nilou:
Traveler, Paimon! I think I've messed up big time...
Nilou:
What if Inayah never planned to come back?
Paimon:
What!?
Nilou:
It's just a gut feeling, but knowing her, she probably feels like she's completely responsible for what happened.
Nilou:
She probably thinks that all of this happened because she was staying here.
Paimon:
Oh right, as soon as her father showed up, she said that her father was targeting her. So she's felt like that this whole time...
Nilou:
She has a long-standing conflict with her father. That's why she ran away from home.
Nilou:
She doesn't think that we can win the debate, and she doesn't want to implicate us, so she thought leaving was the best thing to do...
Paimon:
Mhm, and then she just quietly left afterward...
Nilou:
Exactly. She's being too pessimistic. How will you know if you don't try?
Nilou:
Anyway, first things first, we have to get her back!
Paimon:
...But where should we start? Sumeru is huge!
Nilou:
I think I might know. Let's start by looking outside the city.
Nilou:
Before I brought her to Zubayr Theater, she was staying at a remote campsite. She got a fever from drinking unclean water, so I carried her back.
Nilou:
If she has nowhere else to go after leaving the theater, she might go back and strike out on her own again.
Paimon:
Then let's go take a look!
Nilou:
Yes, let's hurry.
Find Inayah outside the city
Nilou:
There are signs that someone had stayed here very recently...
Paimon:
But we can't confirm if it was Inayah or not.
Paimon:
Let's take a look around first!
Inayah:
Aaah—!
You hear Inayah's voice...
Paimon:
Did you hear that?
Nilou:
I heard it, too. Let's investigate.
Get close to the direction where the sound is from
Paimon:
It sounds like we're getting closer. The voice is coming from over there!
Nilou:
Yeah, we're almost there!
Inayah:
Stay back!
Paimon:
It's Inayah! She's being attacked by wild animals!
Nilou:
Inayah, don't be scared! We're coming to help!
You rescue Inayah, who had been surrounded by beasts.
Talk to Inayah
Inayah:
Th—Thank you...
Inayah:
There weren't so many big animals in this area before. They chased after me for a long time...
Inayah:
Sorry, I'm causing trouble for you again...
Nilou:
Why did you leave by yourself?
Nilou:
You really don't think we have a chance at winning the debate?
Inayah:
No, I just thought it would take too much effort.
Inayah:
Everything happened because of me. If I'm gone, then the situation will resolve itself.
Traveler:
But everyone else is trying so hard.
Paimon:
Yeah! Everyone's working together towards a happier ending. No one should be singled out for blame.
Inayah:
It's alright if it's me. As long as the theater won't get demolished...
Inayah:
You guys are the kindest people I've ever met. You shouldn't suffer so much because of me.
Nilou:
Listen to me, Inayah.
Nilou:
Even if you were the reason that all of this happened, no one would blame you.
Nilou:
Mr. Zubayr said that you're one of us, so that means we will protect you.
Nilou:
No matter what happens, we'll stand as one.
Inayah:
Nilou, there will always be a victim, whether it's me or the theater. You can't eat your cake and have it, too.
Inayah:
You can't win a debate against the Akademiya, especially since your opponent will be my father.
Traveler:
Why are you so sure of this?
Inayah:
My father is an extremely demanding man.
Inayah:
He's always wanted me to become an exceptional researcher and his academic successor.
Inayah:
I tried my best to meet his expectations, and did everything I could.
Inayah:
But he still wasn't satisfied... or rather, he had just never been satisfied with me.
Inayah:
I'm no genius, but whenever he berated me, it was always as if he was asking me, "Why aren't you a genius?"
Inayah:
Yeah, like I'd know...
Paimon:
So that's why you ran away from home?
Inayah:
At first, I thought that Father would slowly come to terms with reality, but he just wouldn't stop berating me.
Inayah:
For one exam, I earned the third-highest score.
Inayah:
I thought that all my hard work had finally paid off, that I could finally make Father feel some modicum of joy.
Inayah:
I even used the embroidery skills I learned at school to make a commemorative gift for him.
Inayah:
I thought... "Even this daughter can make her father happy sometimes, right?"
Nilou:
I see... When we were embroidering your gift before, I didn't feel like you were new at it.
Inayah:
Yeah, sorry for not bringing it up. These are not pleasant memories for me.
Inayah:
I was tired of him yelling at me every day. All I wanted was to see him smile at me.
Inayah:
But... He was more angry than ever before once I'd given him my embroidery and told him my score. He flung my present to the side.
Inayah:
"You think you should be proud of third place? Reflect on why you weren't first!"
Inayah:
I forgot how long I had cried for. I only remember my parents arguing. My mother also thought he went overboard.
Inayah:
They argued for such a long time. My father eventually stormed out and slammed the door behind him. I didn't get a single sentence of apology, or any words of comfort...
Inayah:
I've completely given up. We're destined to never understand each other.
Nilou:
How horrible...
Inayah:
I don't think you can beat him in a debate, because he doesn't even understand what kind of place a theater is.
Inayah:
He can never understand the relationship performers have with their audience. His life is devoid of camaraderie or friendship.
Inayah:
He just wants everything to happen according to his wishes, as if the world revolves around him.
Inayah:
What we cherish — our little place in this world — means nothing to him...
Paimon:
It sounds like your past has had a huge impact on you.
Nilou:
I understand now, Inayah.
Nilou:
But, when we were preparing for the debate, I heard something quite wise. Maybe it'll help you.
Rekhar once said that "The most important thing about an experience is how you choose to interpret it."
Nilou:
Ms. Rekhar has gone through a lot in her life, but she told us that she's very happy to live at the theater now.
Nilou:
Although she ran into misfortune, it led her down a new path in life. She sees that as a blessing.
Nilou:
She told me that the most important thing about an experience is how you choose to interpret it.
Inayah:
Interpret it...?
Nilou:
I can sympathize with your unhappiness at home, but after you ran away, you ended up at the theater and became one of us.
Nilou:
Those unhappy experiences allowed you to really cherish your bonds with everyone, and also gave you the opportunity to become friends with us.
Nilou:
Don't let your past suffering keep you from the new life that you've worked so hard to find.
Inayah:
Oh...
Paimon:
Let the past stay in the past.
Inayah:
When I ran away from home, I swore that I would leave my family conflict behind...
Inayah:
But you're right, all I'm doing now is falling right back into it...
Nilou:
Maybe you'll disappoint him, but that doesn't matter. You have a new future waiting for you.
Nilou:
Don't let go of the answer you've worked so hard to find.
Paimon:
That's right! If we put our heads together, there's bound to be a way!
Inayah:
You're right, there's nothing to be afraid of.
Inayah:
I'm not trying to meet his expectations, so why should I give up because of him?
Inayah:
I can't afford to lose anything more... We have to win.
Inayah:
The debate will not only protect Zubayr Theater, but also allow me to settle things with Father.
Traveler:
That's right.
Paimon:
That's the spirit!
Inayah:
Let's go. I'll tell my father about the debate.
Inayah:
I know him very well. Even if he looks down on us, I know how to make him accept.
Nilou:
Alright, let's go.
Go back to Sumeru City together
Inayah:
Well, I'm off to meet with him. Please wait here for me.
Nilou:
Okay. Looking forward to your good news.
Nilou:
Phew, that should be everything. The only thing left to do now is to wait until the debate.
Nilou:
I'm not sure why, but I'm getting nervous again.
Paimon:
You were great, Nilou! Your words won over Inayah.
Paimon:
Talk like that during the debate, and you'll get an easy win!
Nilou:
Thanks for that, Paimon.
Nilou:
But I still feel like it'll be an uphill battle. I need to be calmer, cooler, and more collected.
Nilou:
Yeah. I'm acting as everyone's representative, so I'll need to act brave, even if I won't feel like it.
Traveler:
There's still one problem left unsolved.
Nilou:
Huh? What's left?
Paimon:
Huh? What a strange question...
Paimon:
Isn't a theater just a theater? Why would it need to be anything else?
Nilou:
Wait... You're not asking what the theater DOES, but what it IS.
Nilou:
Lemme think... Um, how can I put this? Hmm...
Nilou carefully recalls what everyone said along the way...
Nilou:
Ah, got it!
Nilou:
When we were trying to find a way to save the theater, we heard many stories not of the theater, but of the people whose lives have been touched by it.
Nilou:
Zubayr Theater is our reason for coming together. It connects us all in unique ways.
Nilou:
In other words, it's like a bond!
Paimon:
A bond?
Nilou:
The theater provides money for Ms. Rekhar and her children, inspiration for Mr. Khasani, and enjoyment for the people of the Great Bazaar.
Nilou:
It also gives Inayah shelter from her family... It has brought us together after taking care of every single one of us.
Nilou:
And its story won't end here. In the future, many more people will come to the theater and receive its blessing.
Nilou:
And we'll all be there for them. Our warm, welcoming community will show them the same kindness we were shown in the past.
Nilou:
Aside from the delivery of performances, isn't this another reason for Zubayr Theater's continued existence?
Paimon:
Yeah, that makes sense! We definitely felt that warmth during the preparations for the event.
Paimon:
But, Paimon doesn't see how this will help in the debate.
Paimon:
Oh, gotcha. No matter how strong an opponent is, they'll have to go on the defensive if pressed on a weak point!
Nilou:
I feel like that's another prong in our attack. Thank you so much.
Paimon:
Paimon also feels a lot more relieved. Let's show him what we got!
Inayah:
Sorry for the wait. I'm back.
Inayah:
Things went a lot more smoothly than I expected. It didn't take long for him to accept the debate, and is set for two days from now.
Inayah:
...Why are you all smiling so much? Did something good happen?
Paimon:
We realized that your dad might not be as scary as we had thought.
Nilou:
Hee-hee, we've just finished our prep. Rest easy, it will all turn out well!
Nilou:
We have to win... No, we WILL win, Inayah.
Inayah:
Hehe, fingers crossed!
Everything is ready and now it's up to Nilou's performance in the debate.
Go to the theater and witness the debate
Safwan:
Hello and welcome, everyone. I am Safwan, a scholar from the Akademiya, and I will serve as this debate's adjudicator.
Safwan:
I swear to judge both parties with the utmost wisdom and impartiality. I will neither interfere with the proceedings nor demonstrate bias.
Safwan:
I ask for both parties to stand. May the Dendro Archon also serve as a witness to this duel of wits.
Sharif:
Since you so desperately demand an explanation, I will expound on the Akademiya's stance.
Sharif:
You may have misunderstood us from the outset, and believed that the Akademiya is prejudiced against you.
Sharif:
However, the truth is that the Akademiya wishes for every resident of Sumeru to be afforded opportunities to grow and cultivate their wisdom.
Sharif:
Therefore, the works they consume should also possess enlightening qualities and intellectual value.
Sharif:
We have failed to identify these qualities in the shows performed at Zubayr Theater.
Sharif:
In other words, instead of struggling against the Akademiya in pointless confrontations, if you had spent your time reflecting on improving the quality of your shows and enlightening your audience...
Sharif:
Zubayr Theater would not be today facing such a tragic fate.
Paimon:
Aggressive from the get-go. He's really putting on the pressure...!
Paimon:
Can Nilou stand her ground?
Nilou:
(Calm down, Nilou... First, carefully analyze what he said.)
Nilou:
(He said that we were shut down not because the Akademiya looks down on the arts, but rather because our shows aren't up to their standards. However...)
Nilou ponders for a while and recalls the ideas she has collected from her previous exchanges with everyone. All residents of the Grand Bazaar believes that "Everyone is free to appreciate art — no form of art is inherently superior." This is a fitting argument against Sharif.
Nilou:
In your eyes, our shows can't meet the Akademiya's expectations.
Nilou:
Shouldn't it be the audience who decides if a show is intellectual or enlightening? Why is someone from the Akademiya judging that?
Nilou:
Also, I believe that there is no such thing as a wiser or more enlightening performance.
Nilou:
Art doesn't discriminate, and it appeals to all. Everyone has the right to appreciate art.
Sharif:
Appreciation is but a primitive form of satisfaction. Guidance and enlightenment are necessary if we are to induce growth in the performers as well as the audience.
Sharif:
This stance holds performers to a higher standard and encourages the development of the arts.
Sharif:
If all performances are simple-minded, require little effort to comprehend, and lack any impetus for the betterment of society, then the people will not be able to develop a greater level of artistic understanding.
Sharif:
Nurturing the populace's understanding requires a long and arduous process, and guiding this process is the Akademiya's true goal.
Nilou:
(He changed the topic without batting an eye! Good thing I'm prepared.)
Nilou:
(If I remember correctly, what I should say here is...)
"Art must first be appreciated by others to confer value," said Khasani. This is a fitting argument against Sharif.
Nilou:
Someone at our theater has tried that before.
Nilou:
He was a famed artist, but he recognized that very few people could connect with his works.
Nilou:
I agree that art should be enlightening, but we can't pursue that goal by creating complicated works.
Nilou:
If a work can't tap into an audience's personal experiences or feelings, then its contents may as well be a castle in the sky.
Nilou:
What's the point of performing a show that its audience can't even follow?
Nilou:
That would only be forcing people to watch something they don't like.
Sharif:
You can only reach that conclusion from a place of ignorance.
Nilou:
In that case, before passing judgment, you should first become a better dancer than me.
Farhad:
You tell them, Nilou!
Kourosh:
Looks like he's backed himself into a corner...
Safwan:
As the party holding the burden of proof, Sharif has failed to provide sufficient support for his judgment of the quality of Zubayr Theater's programs.
Safwan:
Likewise, the definition that Nilou put forth is but her personal opinion. Neither party is the victor for this particular point of contention.
Safwan:
...Additionally, I must request that both parties exercise greater control on their emotions.
Paimon:
Keep it up, Nilou! You're doing great!
Sharif:
In that case, I shall speak of more concrete matters. The essence of this issue is that you have violated the law, so you must now pay the price for your transgression.
Sharif:
This course of action is also completely procedurally sound. We have already contacted Zubayr Theater multiple times regarding the theater's repertoire.
Sharif:
However, you have consciously ignored our warnings — or perhaps your compliance was purely superficial. Regardless, that failure has indirectly led to the present day's proceedings.
Safwan:
That is indeed so, according to the laws decreed by the Akademiya.
Nilou:
(He's started talking about procedural stuff, so I need to focus on...)
Nilou remembers how Mr. Zubayr meticulously manages the theater and makes sure that everything checks out. This is a fitting argument against Sharif.
Nilou:
Mr. Zubayr has already provided signed copies of all documentation related to our operations. Everything is perfectly filled out and valid.
Nilou:
Although the theater's performances don't align with the Akademiya's requests, the law doesn't say that Zubayr Theater can be demolished only because of that reason.
Nilou:
Demolition notices need to be provided in writing and made available to the public. Otherwise, the theater can continue to operate as long as its license is valid.
Nilou:
Failing to follow these rules makes your stance procedurally unsound.
Abhi:
Yeah, yeah!
Sohrin:
That's right!
Sharif:
...There are different ways to apply the rules. There is precedent for this.
Sharif:
So long as this matter is discussed within the Akademiya, this course of action will come to pass.
Safwan:
Looking at the past 27 cases of similar nature, 90% of them support Sharif's claim and position.
Safwan:
However, the demolition process in those cases was only started after discussion at the Akademiya. In other words, premature notice of demolition is indeed a rash act.
Nilou:
That's more than enough. We've proven that the order is unreasonable as it currently stands.
Sharif:
...Hmph. Cease your futile resistance.
Paimon:
Nilou's definitely won this point, right?
Paimon:
You're right... Stay focused, Nilou!
Sharif:
Even if permission for demolition has yet to be obtained, it is a fact that your performances violated the Akademiya's policies on numerous occasions.
Sharif:
Based on that fact, we can permanently revoke your right to perform in Sumeru.
Nilou:
Ah...
Safwan:
Under the current system, it is indeed possible to immediately revoke Zubayr Theater's performing rights.
Paimon:
That's a thing!?
Sharif:
Rather than protecting Zubayr Theater, I surmise that your true intention is to maintain your hold over your audience, and their patronage as your source of income.
Sharif:
Without them, Zubayr Theater is nothing more than an empty building.
Sharif:
And without its performances, the theater has nothing else of value.
Nilou:
What you said isn't true at all!
Paimon:
Ahh, keep it cool, Nilou!
Nilou:
(Right, I need to keep calm, but he...)
Nilou:
(Just a little more. Zubayr Theater isn't just a performance venue to us...)
Nilou remembers that you once argued that the theater carries everyone's feelings, and serves as the bond that connects us all.
Nilou:
Zubayr Theater isn't simply a performance venue to us — it means more than that. It's been our home for a long time.
Nilou:
Ms. Rekhar can't go on adventures anymore, but she has found a stable career and a new life at the theater.
Nilou:
Her son, Sohrin, has already passed his theater exam, and he'll soon be our newest member.
Nilou:
Mr. Khasani found a new way to look at art. He decided to stay at the theater to watch us grow.
Nilou:
Mr. Farhad and Mr. Hushang visit even when there isn't a show going on, and they always tell us lots of entertaining stories.
Nilou:
Even Inayah wants to stay with us, and she's starting to look forward to a new future.
Nilou:
Zubayr Theater exists for them... for every single one of us!
Sharif:
Perhaps Zubayr Theater has provided you with a multitude of positive emotions and experiences. However, you have misconstrued something, young miss.
Sharif:
The interpersonal relationships you speak of were established upon normal theater operations.
Sharif:
Sheikh Zubayr operates the theater for his livelihood, his employees work for their wages, and the audience comes to enjoy performances.
Sharif:
Relationships are merely a byproduct in this exchange of interests. They may be pleasant and captivating, but they can only ever be secondary.
Sharif:
When scholars collaborate to solve difficult problems, we freely share our knowledge and resources with one another, as if we were all kin.
Sharif:
However, this collaboration ends after the results of our work are published.
Sharif:
The reason is simple: We are scholars, and there are new projects that await our attention.
Paimon:
He really doesn't think much of relationships. Paimon also thinks he did a lot of prep — he's been solid as a rock.
Safwan:
Sharif's argument is currently the more persuasive of the two for this point of contention.
Safwan:
The continuance of the interpersonal relationships Nilou spoke of remains hypothetical before the theater's demolition, whereas the situation that Sharif described has been well documented at the Akademiya.
Safwan:
The Akademiya has made significant academic contributions in no small part due to its researchers' efficiency and ability to compartmentalize.
Paimon:
Oh no, what should we do? Things are going in the opposite direction...
Paimon:
A set-up? So Nilou's got him?
Nilou:
(Good, he's said what he said. The next argument could decide this debate.)
Nilou:
(But... is this really the best thing to do? It might be too cruel to Inayah...)
Nilou remembers what Inayah said. She really wants to win and doesn't want to lose anything else because of her painful past.
Nilou:
(She already agreed to this. She wants to win, no matter what. Me too.)
Nilou:
Mr. Sharif believes that interpersonal relationships are a byproduct of working towards a goal. Once that goal is achieved or abandoned, those relationships would have no more reason to continue.
Nilou:
Then, if someone has failed to live up to his expectations—
Inayah:
If someone has failed to live up to your expectations and ran away from home, then she shouldn't be your daughter anymore, right?
Nilou:
Inayah...
Inayah:
Sorry Nilou, as expected, I should be the one to say it. You don't need to shoulder this responsibility for me.
Sharif:
...
Inayah:
If in your eyes, the purpose of my existence is to become your academic successor, then that goal has ended in complete failure.
Inayah:
By your logic, that means there is no more reason to sustain our relationship as father and daughter.
Safwan:
Members of the audience who do not belong to either debate party, please speak with caution.
Sharif:
Let her speak.
Sharif:
What she does not say, Nilou will.
Inayah:
No matter how many disagreements we've had, the truth is that you are still my father.
Inayah:
You're so immersed in your own world that you can't understand why we come together for the sake of relationships.
Rekhar:
Yeah, don't look down on us!
Farhad:
You can watch a dance anywhere, but there's only one Zubayr Theater!
Sheikh Zubayr:
I'm almost starting to feel sorry for this guy, what with the idiotic things he's said.
Safwan:
Order, order! Members of the audience, do not interrupt debate proceedings!
Inayah:
I confess that this is the final argument we had prepared. Disown me, and you will win the debate.
Inayah:
But before that, Father, I have some final words to say.
Inayah:
I've been doing some soul-searching. Not about whether I should have run away from home, but whether there was any point to my personal rebellion against you.
Inayah:
I kept trying to earn your approval, but I only disappointed you over and over. The truth is, I ran away from home as a means to vent my recurring frustrations.
Inayah:
That is to say, I was exerting pressure on you, and hoping you'd give up on your lofty expectations.
Inayah:
But by doing that, wasn't I just doing the same thing as you?
Sharif:
...
Inayah:
I won't force my expectations upon you anymore. At Zubayr Theater, I have found the life I've always wanted.
Inayah:
I will move on from my family troubles and strive towards my new goal.
Inayah:
But if you dare to harm this place, then I will stand with my friends here and fight against you.
Safwan:
This is not the time to space out, Sharif. The debate is still underway.
Sharif:
...You already consider them to be your friends?
Sheikh Zubayr:
You should be asking US that question.
Sohrin:
Of course we are!
Abhi:
Miss Inayah is a really good friend!
Khasani:
It was a bit of a process, but we won her over.
Nilou:
Make no mistake:
Nilou:
All those who come to Zubayr Theater become one of us. We will always be with her.
Sharif:
Hmph, such puerile simplicity. However...
Sharif:
It is surprisingly a relief.
After saying that, Sharif turns and walks away.
Safwan:
Wait, what are you...? Ah, never mind.
Nilou:
They... left?
Rekhar:
Does that mean we've won?
Kourosh:
We won?
Paimon:
Nilou, you're amazing!
Nilou:
Ha... Haha...
Nilou:
I relaxed for a moment, and... I feel a little faint...
Nilou:
It looks like he still has a place for her in his heart.
Sheikh Zubayr:
Terrific work, Nilou and Inayah. They likely won't cause any more trouble for us.
Farhad:
Didn't know you could get so fierce. I have a lot of newfound respect for you two.
Nilou:
This really took a lot out of me, though. *sigh* I don't ever wanna do this again...
Sohrin:
Both Miss Nilou and Miss Inayah were so cool!
Rekhar:
Should we throw a second round of celebrations?
The curtain finally falls on the debate amidst a euphony of cheers...
Talk to Nilou
Nilou:
Oh, it's you.
Traveler:
Feeling any calmer?
Nilou:
Yes, I feel a lot better. The more I think back on everything, the more surreal it all feels.
Nilou:
I don't think I could repeat what I did a second time.
Traveler:
All of our preparations paid off.
Nilou:
Yes, and it's all thanks to you.
Nilou:
Hehe, I see. You mean how fate brought me to the theater, right?
Nilou:
Then, I'll have to tell you about my teacher, who Mr. Zubayr had mentioned.
Nilou:
Mr. Zubayr opened his theater when I was still a child.
Nilou:
There was a beautiful dancer, and from the moment I saw her, I couldn't look away.
Nilou:
I thought to myself, "The gods must have blessed her with such talent."
Nilou:
But later on, she would actually smile down at me and say, "Just the opposite, in fact."
Traveler:
The opposite?
Nilou:
Yeah. She said, "Dance is an art born from toil. It isn't a gift from the gods, but a creation by our own hands."
Nilou:
"It is a beautiful thing born from our life experiences. Whenever there is joy or something to be celebrated, people will dance."
Nilou:
"In other words, any place where people can effortlessly begin a dance will for sure be filled with the blessings of everyone's happiness."
Nilou:
She wasn't looking for flowers and applause — all she wanted was to see her audience smile.
Nilou:
Right, the same as what Mr. Khasani believes.
Nilou:
I was completely moved by what she had said, so I started taking dance lessons from her. And later on, I began to dance here in her stead.
Nilou:
Before she retired, she told me, "For as long as you live, never forget what dance means to others."
Nilou:
This is why Mr. Zubayr and I never intended to listen to the Akademiya.
Nilou:
Even though it ended up causing everyone a whole lot of trouble, thankfully, everything worked out in the end.
Nilou:
Mhm, although I do have a small regret.
Traveler:
Inayah?
Nilou:
Yeah. Even though she has already decided to stop fighting with her father, they never managed to have a real conversation with each other.
Nilou:
Before he left, Mr. Sharif looked like he had a lot on his mind.
Nilou:
He probably has a lot of things he wants to say, but will now perhaps never get a chance to.
Nilou:
Yeah, but I still hope that things can change. It never hurts to have hope.
Nilou:
You and Paimon are more than welcome to keep attending our shows.
Nilou:
Hehe, who knows, next time, you might see Inayah on the stage.
Paimon:
Are you still worried about Inayah?
Paimon:
Let's be sure to come back often. Who knows, maybe things will have worked out for her!
Go to the theater to see Inayah
Nilou:
Everyone, I'd like to introduce you to our newest member: Inayah!
Inayah:
H—Hello, everyone...
Nilou:
She'll be dancing for us from now on, so please give her your support.
Paimon:
Inayah's taken her place on the stage! Paimon wonders how she'll look once she starts dancing.
Paimon:
When you stop and think about it, happy endings like this sure aren't easy to come by!
Traveler:
A lot of things came together to make it happen.
Paimon:
Nilou's efforts, everyone's wisdom, Inayah's determination...
Traveler:
And Sharif's mercy.
Paimon:
Huh? What do you mean by that?
Paimon:
You do have a point there...
Paimon:
The whole demolition thing was going overboard, but he really could've banned Nilou and the others from dancing.
Paimon:
If he really wanted to be ruthless, he could've done some real damage, even without winning the debate.
Paimon:
Oh well, it's not like we can understand how people like him think. Let's focus on watching the performance!
Paimon:
Huh!? Wait, look who the cat dragged in!
Paimon:
Isn't that Inayah's father!?
Traveler:
Let's go greet him.
Sharif:
Oh, it's you two.
Sharif:
I don't have much to do today, so I just came to look around this place.
Paimon:
Hmph, are you looking for Inayah?
Sharif:
No, I am simply here to watch a performance. There is no need to trouble her.
Traveler:
Shouldn't you be busy?
Sharif:
Well, I was, for a time.
Sharif:
My loss at the debate caused quite the loss of face for the Akademiya, so there was a period of unrest.
Sharif:
I used this opportunity to suggest that my superiors temporarily suspend me from duty. Otherwise, the rumors would probably persist for even longer.
Paimon:
Suspended from duty...
Sharif:
Yes, I am temporarily unemployed. However, I now have an abundance of time, so I can afford to come here and watch a show.
Sharif:
I admit that I do not understand the magic that this theater possesses, but my curiosity has been piqued.
Sharif:
I still cannot forget that young lady's perseverance. Inayah would almost certainly mature in the presence of such a person.
Traveler:
So you're still concerned about your daughter.
Sharif:
There are no parents who do not worry about their children. I suppose she managed to hit a weak spot of mine.
Sharif:
Never mind. I do not have the right to say that.
Paimon:
You're already here, so you might as well go see her.
Sharif:
No, that is not necessary. I will take my leave after the show concludes.
Sharif:
...Do not tell her that I was here.
While you are having a conversation, Nilou pushes the reluctant Inayah to your side. She beckons you to step aside and leave some private space for the estranged father and daughter.
After seeing his daughter again, Sharif takes out a work of embroidery from his bag — his attempt to make up for the hurt his daughter has received. Seeing this, Inayah hesitates for a while. Then with mixed emotions, she takes the embroidering, hoping that she can have a calm talk with her father.
Paimon:
Like father, like daughter. They're both so awkward with their feelings!
Nilou:
Yeah, she probably would've snuck away as well if I didn't drag her back.
Paimon:
Do you think they'll be able to reconcile?
Nilou:
I'm not sure. A complete reconciliation may also not be the best thing for them right now.
Nilou:
All those years of arguments and misunderstandings can't be settled overnight. It might be best if they continue to keep some distance for now.
Nilou:
But no matter where their hearts and bodies may be, they will always be family.
Nilou:
All I wish for them is to be able to one day tap into the warmth of that bond.
Nilou:
Oh, by the way, everyone's really thankful to you for helping out with the debate.
Nilou:
So we made you a little something. Hope you'll like it!
Paimon:
I—Isn't this Zubayr Theater?
Paimon:
Whoa, this is amazing... It's so detailed and polished...
Nilou:
Hee-hee, we've also never made anything this complicated before.
Nilou:
Mr. Zubayr and Mr. Khasani took charge of the design, while Inayah and I made all the little pieces with the help of others.
Nilou:
Ms. Rekhar and Miss Najia made and assembled the centerpiece.
Nilou:
As adventurers, you two will doubtlessly travel to many more lands and see many more things.
Nilou:
That's why we hope that your time at Zubayr Theater will become a fond memory of your journey. You two are welcome back anytime!
Paimon:
Mhm, we'll come back and watch you dance whenever we get the chance!
Nilou:
You're welcome, and there's no need to be so polite. You learned fast!
Nilou:
Come on, take it. This is the story of you and me. It's a tale that I'll never, ever forget.